The Right Slice: Kauaʻi’s Sweet and Savory Pie Haven

Kauaʻi’s culinary landscape is rich with island flavors, but few places capture that spirit quite like The Right Slice. More than a bakery, it’s a celebration of local produce and handmade craftsmanship, nestled in Kalaheo since 2014. Whether you’re a visitor or a local, this spot invites you to savor Hawaiian-inspired pies in a warm, casual atmosphere.

Walking into The Right Slice, I was greeted by the unmistakable aroma of butter crusts baking fresh, mingling with tropical notes from the display case. Owner Sandy Poehnelt’s devotion to island ingredients shines through every pie, from the tangy Passionfruit (lilikoi) Cheesecake to the indulgent Mango–Lilikoi pie. It’s clear these pies don’t just feature Hawaiian flavors—they embody the islands’ bounty. I enjoyed a slice of the Blueberry Pina Colada pie, where juicy blueberries met creamy coconut in a flaky, golden crust. The buttery crust, a highlight across their offerings, provided a perfect balance: sturdy but tender, never dry.

The savory side impressed just as much. Sampling the Classic Chicken Pot Pie revealed a hearty, well-seasoned filling wrapped in that same delicious crust, a comforting reminder of home-style cooking with island flair. Staff were knowledgeable and friendly, offering great pairing suggestions and explaining their rotating menu—meatloaf and hot dog pies often appear as fun specials. The bakery’s bright, no-fuss setting encourages grabbing a slice to go, though a few indoor tables make for a quick sit-down.

Highlights & Tips

• Handmade butter crusts excel in texture and flavor, a consistent standout.
• Pies showcase island-grown fruits like passionfruit, mango, and coconut, supporting local farmers.
• Gluten-free, vegan, and no-sugar-added pies offer inclusive options.
• Popular flavors can sell out by afternoon; best to visit mid-morning.
• Moderate pricing ($5–7 per slice) may feel steep but quality justifies the cost.

One caveat: some slices felt smaller than expected for the price, especially if you’re used to larger portions. Also, the tanginess in the lilikoi fillings, though pleasant, might not satisfy those craving a sharper passionfruit punch.

Verdict

The Right Slice is a must for pie lovers seeking genuine Hawaiian flavors and artisan quality. It’s perfect for casual bites, special occasions, or a take-home treat that doubles as a Kauaʻi souvenir. If you favor generous portions over premium ingredients or want a formal dining experience, this isn’t your spot. But for anyone enchanted by fresh island fruit, flaky crusts, and a friendly, laid-back vibe, The Right Slice is well worth the visit.